THE ARISING · Longevity & Healthspan
Shingles Vaccination and Dementia: An Encouraging Link, Not Proven Prevention
Shingles vaccination has an established purpose: preventing shingles and its complications. A separate question has emerged from studies of older adults: could vaccination also reduce the chance of a later dementia diagnosis?
A new systematic review in Vaccines examined 36 reports, 25 of them primary investigations. Across several kinds of studies, the results generally pointed toward fewer dementia diagnoses among people who received a shingles vaccine. But the reviewers graded the certainty for every dementia outcome very low. They concluded that the evidence does not support a dementia-prevention indication.
One of the most informative comparisons comes from Wales. When it introduced an older, live shingles vaccine, eligibility depended on a strict date-of-birth cutoff. A study in Nature compared people born just before and just after that cutoff. Rather than comparing people who freely chose whether to get vaccinated, the researchers used the change in eligibility to estimate the effect of receiving the vaccine.
The estimate was 3.5 percentage points fewer new dementia diagnoses over seven years, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.6 to 7.1 points fewer. That is an absolute difference. The relative difference was estimated at about 20%. Both figures describe the same comparison, and neither is an expected effect for everyone who gets vaccinated today.
The design is stronger than simply comparing volunteers with non-volunteers, but it still depends on assumptions about how similar the groups were around the cutoff. It used a different vaccine from the one the CDC currently recommends in the United States. It also counted diagnoses; that does not establish whether the onset of disease changed, rather than when it was detected.
People can ask about shingles vaccination for its established purpose without waiting for the dementia question to be settled. That question deserves its own trials and its own evidence.