THE ARISING · Longevity & Healthspan · Long Reads
A Study Found No Clear Drop in Brain Weight With Age Across Four Great Ape Groups
Total brain weight is a broad measure. It cannot show that individual brain regions or cognitive abilities stay unchanged.
How much of the human brain’s aging do we share with our closest living relatives? Research published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences puts one part of that question to a test: whether the brain as a whole becomes lighter in older animals.
Branka Hrvoj-Mihic and colleagues examined brain weight across the adult age range of chimpanzees, bonobos, gorillas and orangutans. The researchers did not find a statistically clear decline in total brain weight with age in the groups they studied. In a subset of chimpanzees, that result held when the researchers accounted for body weight. The study suggests that marked loss of total brain weight is not a general feature of aging in these apes.
A separate PNAS study in 2011 took a different approach. It compared MRI scans from 99 chimpanzees with scans from 87 humans. Across the age ranges sampled, the human participants had smaller volumes at older ages across the structures measured; the chimpanzee data did not show the same pattern. The ages beyond the maximum lifespan of the chimpanzees contributed importantly to the apparent human decline. That makes a longer lifespan one hypothesis worth testing, not an explanation established by the newer brain-weight study.
There is more to brain aging than weight or volume. A cross-sectional study compares different individuals of different ages, not the same brains tracked over decades. Total brain weight can also look stable while a particular region changes, and neither study shows that the species are free of age-related cognitive change.
For longevity research, the value is in the comparison. Instead of assuming that marked loss of total brain weight must come with aging in all large-brained primates, researchers can ask where the trajectories diverge and why. This work does not establish a preventive treatment or a new clinical test.