THE ARISING · Sleep & Circadian Health
Food and Housing Security Were Linked to More Regular Sleep
Most sleep advice starts at bedtime. A study in JAMA Network Open started with a different question: are the circumstances in which people live reflected in how long and how consistently they sleep?
Researchers analyzed records from 12,403 adults in the National Institutes of Health’s All of Us Research Program who had at least 180 days of Fitbit sleep data. The median observation period was 982 days. The researchers compared wearable estimates of sleep with survey answers about social connections, economic stability, neighborhood conditions and access to health care.
After adjustment for several differences between participants, people in the top third of the combined social conditions score slept an estimated 5.8 minutes longer per night than people in the bottom third. The 95% confidence interval ran from 3.8 to 7.8 minutes longer. The statistical measure of night-to-night variation in sleep length was about 4.8 minutes lower in the more advantaged group.
Economic stability, as defined in the survey, showed the strongest association among the domains examined. People reporting food security and no housing problems averaged 10.7 minutes more sleep than people reporting both food insecurity and housing problems, with a confidence interval of 5.3 to 16.1 minutes.
These are group averages from observational data. The study did not assign housing or financial assistance, and it did not show that changing either would add a specific number of minutes to someone’s sleep. The wearable estimates are not a clinical sleep test, and the clinical significance of these modest differences is uncertain. Participants were disproportionately White and college educated; the pattern may not apply equally to other groups.
The findings are a reason to ask what gets in the way of sleep before assuming bedside habits are the entire problem. They are not a reason to chase a few minutes on a device. A better next study would ask whether changes in living conditions are followed by changes in sleep, and whether those differences matter to people during the day.